查看單個文章
  #8  
舊 2009-02-02, 10:02 PM
chami chami 目前離線
進階會員
 
註冊日期: 2005-08-19
住址: 104台北市中山北路二段46號12樓
文章: 353
發送 Skype™ 消息給 chami
預設 肯塔基事件的後續最新發展,中英文版.

肯塔基上訴法院駁回州政府欲沒收域名的原因如下:
1、上訴法院認為域名不構成賭博設施,也就是說肯塔基的州法律裡所規範的條文中,域名 不是構成賭博設施的基本要件。
2、本身案件並沒有進行刑事程序,因此也沒有正當的程序可走民事沒收動作。
因此,上訴法院純粹以法的角度來看待這件事情時,其實是回歸到法條本身對於域名是否為賭博的設施,存在著不同的見解。
在上訴法院中,兩位法官持著第一點以及第二點的觀念,認為州政府對於此案不適用賭博條例,以及程序不符規定...等,因此駁回州法院的沒收動作。

但是上訴法院中,一位法官是與州法院有相同觀念,認為州法律的賭博條文中,域名是符合該購成要件,因此在二比一的比數上,上訴法院才駁回州法院的沒收動作。

所以其實此案並未提及肯塔基有沒有權利去沒收域名,而是上訴法院純粹以法律的構成要件審查域名是否為賭博設施。

若今天州法律的法條有延伸規範域名是符合賭博設施的構成要件,則肯塔基政府很有可能就能沒收域名了。

以下是肯塔基事件的原文:

原文:

Kentucky Appeals Court Shuts Down Attempted Domain Seizure
by Chad Kettner in Categories: Legal Issues - 4 Comments

The Kentucky Appeals Court has ruled in a 2-to-1 majority decision against the Commonwealth of Kentucky in its attempt to seize 141 valuable gambling domains, overturning the previous decision by Judge Thomas Wingate of the Kentucky Circuit Court and finally putting an end to Governor Steve Beshear’s efforts to shut down any online gambling websites which could be accessed within the state.


Judge Michelle M. Keller, in her majority decision, found that domain names were never classified as illegal gambling devices by Kentucky law, as had been claimed, and therefore the Commonwealth could not rightfully proceed with its seizure:

“(I)t stretches credulity to conclude that a series of numbers, or Internet address, can be said to constitute a ‘machine or any mechanical or other device…designed and manufactured primarily for use in connection with gambling,” Judge Keller wrote. “We are thus convinced that the trial court clearly erred in concluding that the domain names can be construed to be gambling devices.”

Judge Jeff S. Taylor, also in the majority, added that the Commonwealth of Kentucky could not seek a civil forfeiture based on a criminal statute unless there was a criminal proceeding, which there was not. Since this failed to happen, the Commonwealth was overstepping its boundaries by trying to seize property which was outside its jurisdiction.

Judge Micheal Caperton, in his dissenting opinion, stated that Internet domain names played a role in the larger mechanism for gambling - which included computers and Internet service - and thus could be considered a “gambling device” by Kentucky law.

The 2-to-1 decision immediately prohibits the seizure of the 141 domain names by the Commonwealth of Kentucky.

“We are very happy with the court’s ruling today,” said Joe Brennan Jr., chairman of the Interactive Media Entertainment & Gaming Association (iMEGA). “The judges clearly agreed with our interpretation of the law and, thankfully, this reverses what would have been a terrible precedent for our country and the Internet.”

In September 2008, Kentucky seized the long list of domain names - including PokerStars.com, FullTiltPoker.com, BodogLife.com, GoldenPalace.com, Bet21.com, DoylesRoom.com and Rick Schwartz’ IndianCasino.com - stating that the domains were “being used in connection with illegal gambling activity” within the state.

The seizure created an uproar in the domain community, with the Internet Commerce Association (ICA) immediately addressing the situation, GoDaddy refusing to hand over the domains registered through them, and the website owners appealing the decision.

But against all logic, Judge Thomas Wingate of the Kentucky Circuit Court dismissed all objections from the representatives of the 141 domain names and stated that Kentucky did have the right to seize the domains since they were illegal devices used to facilitate gambling within the state borders.

The decision, which also gave domain owners a second chance to maintain control of their domains if they geo-blocked Kentuckians from accessing the websites, didn’t sit well with either side as Governor Steve Beshear didn’t believe the “get out of jail free” card was warranted and the iMEGA filed a motion to stay, claiming Kentucky didn’t have the right to seize domains regardless of any geo-blocking efforts.

In the end, the courts finally sided with the defendants - a monumental decision which will provide added value and security to gambling domain names and websites for now and the foreseeable future.

“We are humbled by this decision and by the overwhelming support received from Internet businesses and free speech organizations everywhere,” said Jeff Ifrah, an attorney representing the Interactive Gaming Council. “The Court of Appeals has now corrected a fundamental misunderstanding by the trial judge in this proceeding of the nature of the Internet and the legality of online poker in Kentucky.”
__________________
網路中文業務部
客服電話:02-2531-9696
地址:104台北市中山北路二段46號12樓
網路中文
回覆時引用此篇文章